BT TV vs Sky TV - Which is best?

BT vs Sky

BT and Sky are two of the biggest broadband providers out there - but what are their pay-TV offerings like?

To put it simply: they're quite different. While Sky offers a massive spread of channels and some top-notch tech, BT gives you the right essentials at a nice low price. Here's exactly what you get with each one.

Thinking about getting fibre broadband with your TV? Take a look at our BT fibre vs Sky fibre guide too. And see our complete BT review and Sky review as well.

BT TV vs Sky TV at a glance

BT TV Sky TV
Packages Starter, Entertainment, Max Sky Entertainment - plus Sky Kids, Sky HD, Sky BoxSets
Number of channels Up to 140+ Up to 350+
Sky Sports Yes, but only Sky Sports Main Event and Extra Yes, full pack
BT Sport Yes, available with any package Yes, but not through Sky directly
Sky Cinema Yes Yes
HD Yes, up to 21 channels, plus 4K UHD content with Max Yes, up to 50+ channels, plus 4K UHD content with Sky Q 2TB
Recording Up to 600 hours (with Max) Up to 1000 hours (with Sky Q 2TB)
Requirements BT broadband, BT fibre in some cases Satellite dish

Cost

BT TV is generally a lot cheaper than Sky TV - although both providers often have special deals and offers on. For an accurate idea of pricing, it's best to compare your options.

Best buy deals
  • Starter + Superfast Fibre + Weekend Calls
    £100 BT Reward Card - see BT's website for further details
    • Online Exclusive
    • Average speed* 50Mbps
    • £59.99 up-front costs
    • Weekend calls inc.
    • Offer ends
    • £35.99 per month
    18 month contract
  • Entertainment + Superfast Fibre + Weekend Calls
    £100 BT Reward Card - see BT's website for further details
    • Online Exclusive
    • Average speed* 50Mbps
    • £19.99 up-front costs
    • Weekend calls inc.
    • Offer ends
    • £44.99 per month
    18 month contract
  • Entertainment + Superfast Fibre 2 + Weekend Calls
    £110 BT Reward Card - see BT's website for further details
    • Online Exclusive
    • Average speed* 67Mbps
    • £9.99 up-front costs
    • Weekend calls inc.
    • Offer ends
    • £54.99 per month
    18 month contract
  • Sky Entertainment + Broadband Unlimited
    Sky Q box
    • Average speed* 11Mbps
    • £39.95 up-front costs
    • Pay as you go phone
    • Offer ends
    • £33.00 per month
    18 month contract
  • Sky Entertainment + Kids + Broadband Unlimited
    Sky Q box
    • Average speed* 11Mbps
    • £39.95 up-front costs
    • Pay as you go phone
    • Offer ends
    • £38.00 per month
    18 month contract
  • Sky Entertainment + Fibre Unlimited
    Sky Q box
    • Average speed* 36Mbps
    • £39.95 up-front costs
    • Pay as you go phone
    • Offer ends
    • £40.00 per month
    18 month contract

*Average speeds are based on the download speeds of at least 50% of customers at peak time (8pm to 10pm). Speed can be affected by a range of technical and environmental factors. The speed you receive where you live may be lower than that listed above. You can check the estimated speed to your property prior to purchasing.

Verdict

Winner

BT typically wins on price, but special offers can change that, so make sure you compare current deals.

Channels

Sky TV boasts several billion channels. Well, okay, not quite that many - but you can get over 350 if you grab all the add-ons. Even its most basic option, the standard Sky Entertainment package, has about 300, including Sky 1 and Sky Atlantic. In fact, Sky TV is one of the only ways to get Sky Atlantic - the other being NOW TV. (See our Sky vs NOW TV comparison here.)

With BT, you get basic Freeview, though the Entertainment and Max packages add a few extra premium ones too. You can get up to 140-ish altogether - plus you can add more with a bolt-on, such as Kids' TV. These give you a bundle of channels on a rolling 30-day basis, so you can add and remove them whenever you want. There's still not as much to watch as there is on Sky, mind you.

Verdict

Winner

This one's obvious. Sky has way more channels, including Sky Atlantic.

Sports TV

BT Sport

Here's the big question from sports enthusiasts: Can you get BT Sport or Sky Sports?

With BT TV, you can get BT Sport included either for free, or very, very cheaply - and it's the only way to get that coveted BT Sport Ultra HD channel for stunning 4K-resolution footie. You can get Sky Sports Main Event and Extra added on for a monthly fee, too - which is fine if you only want to catch flagship games, but perhaps not good enough if you're after the full breadth of sport or certain niche games.

On Sky, you can of course get the full Sky Sports suite, and adding it onto Sky TV is the cheapest way to get it. BT Sport is available to add on too, though you won't get the Ultra HD channel, even with the UHD Sky Q box. Find out how to get BT Sport on Sky in our guide.

Verdict

Winner

Major sports buffs can't get better than Sky. That said, BT is a good option for casual fans who just want to catch the big events - especially as it's quite a bit cheaper.

Equipment and technology

BT's TV getup is based around YouView, a kind of Freeview box that can handle more premium bits and bobs. Depending on which package you choose, you'll either get:

  • A standard YouView box
  • A YouView+ box, which you can record TV onto
  • Or a YouView+ Ultra HD box, which has more recording space and is 4K-ready

Your telly is delivered via your TV aerial and the internet, which means it's nice and easy to set up - but you do need decent enough speeds for most streaming to work. A minimum of 6Mb is required to get BT Sport HD, for instance. Gadget-heavy households that don't have fibre broadband might have problems with buffering.

With Sky TV, you'll get Sky Q - the company's most innovative telly tech yet. It's got features like 'fluid viewing', which lets you pause a programme in one room and pick it up elsewhere; a really user-friendly interface; and a cool touch remote. You can choose either a standard box with 1TB storage (around 500 hours of recordings), or a 2TB, 4K-ready box. Upgrading to the 2TB box is a tad expensive, though.

The downside is that you need a satellite dish to watch Sky TV - which can be a bit of hassle and disruption to install, and isn't always possible for shared or rented homes.

Verdict

Winner

Sky's tech is the best - so long as you're cool with the satellite dish.

On-demand and catch-up

Game of Thrones

Good news - you can catch up with your favourite shows on demand with both Sky and BT.

BT's got 30-day catch-up services from all the main guys, like BBC iPlayer, ITV Hub, and UKTV Play. However, there isn't a lot outside of that - you won't find extra box sets, for instance.

Box sets are more Sky's domain, actually. With the aptly-named Box Sets add-on, you get around 350 box sets to watch, including Game of Thrones - though sadly you don't get any with the base package, and Sky BoxSets will cost you extra each month.

As for 30-day catch-up, it's got that too, with up to 60 channels covered - and more if you have certain add-ons.

Verdict

Winner

Yep, you get more with Sky here.

Our verdict

Sky definitely offers the best pay-TV. It gives you more channels - some really, really good channels for that matter - as well as more impressive tech and a wider spread of on-demand telly.

Here's the thing, though: it's expensive. If your household watches lots of TV, splashing out on the best of the best is worth it… but when you add on box sets, sports, Sky Cinema, and the 2TB set-top box, it does get quite costly.

For just a bit of pay-TV and some premium channels - and BT Sport - BT TV is a lower-priced option, so long as you're happy to sacrifice some features.

See also:

  • NOW Broadband and TV review

  • Virgin Mobile review 2018 - is Virgin Mobile any good?

  • John Lewis Broadband and home phone review

  • EE mobile review 2018 - is it any good?

  • EE vs O2 - Which mobile network is best?

  • BT vs EE broadband - which is best?

  • NOW Broadband and TV review

  • John Lewis Broadband and home phone review

  • BT vs EE broadband - which is best?

  • EE broadband, home phone, and TV review

  • TalkTalk broadband, home phone, and TV review

  • Sky broadband, phone, and TV review